Why people are upset about iPhone charging

Clean Energy Charging helps reduce a user's carbon footprint

Apple quietly included a feature called Clean Energy Charging in iOS 16.1 and turned it on by default. Here's what you need to know about the environmentally conscious feature.

Apple was vocal about Clean Energy Charging when it announced iOS 16 in September 2022. It didn't launch to the public until October 24 with iOS 16.1, and it seemed the change went by without many users noticing — until a recent social media storm.

Sunday, February 26, saw a slew of posts getting attention on Twitter about Clean Energy Charging. Users were vocal and angry, stating that they didn't want Apple to decide how they used energy for them.

The feature is opt-out, so if you don't want to participate in Clean Energy Charging, there is a simple toggle in settings to turn it off.

Before disabling the feature, you should learn about why Apple thinks Clean Energy Charging is important, how it works, and why you should consider leaving it on.

Clean Energy Charging is a feature that reduces a user's carbon footprint based on certain charging habits and local carbon emission forecasts. It is only active during extended charging sessions, like overnight, and in certain repeat locations, like at home or work.

Despite claims made on social media, this feature does not reduce the effectiveness or speed of charging every time a device is plugged in. Instead, it is very selective based on the conditions mentioned before.

Posts and stories claiming that users had to turn off Clean Energy Charging after noticing how slow their iPhone was charging since iOS 16.1 are not accurate. This is based on a misunderstanding of the feature.

Users should not notice any difference in how their iPhone normally charges with Clean Energy Charging enabled.

In the event Clean Energy Charging activates at an inopportune time, users can shut it off and charge normally. If the feature is active, there is a notification available that can be long-pressed to turn it off for that charging session.

Clean Energy Charging doesn't activate without notifying the user. If the feature does suspend charging, the notification will say when the device will reach 100% — similar to the Optimized Battery Charging feature.

Articles and various social media posts suggest that Apple is somehow punishing users who live in areas that have heavy carbon emissions. This is a deliberate misunderstanding of the feature and how it works.

A carbon emission forecast isn't looking for clean energy sources and deciding if your electrical grid is "bad." It is looking for an average of carbon emissions over time and decides when the least carbon emissions are created for a given day — which is net-cleaner. Basically, what the phone is assessing is peak versus non-peak electrical power usage times.

The iPhone feature will look for when carbon emissions are lower on average for the region and wait to charge the iPhone at full speed until then. However, there are other calculations taking place that will be discussed in the next section.

Reducing a user's carbon footprint doesn't mean the user has to ask their electric company to move to new energy sources so they can charge their iPhone faster. What it does mean is for the millions of iPhones in use across the United States, the collective user base can make a difference by charging their device more intentionally in very specific circumstances to reduce carbon emissions.

Multiple things have to be true before the iPhone suspends charging with Clean Energy Charging enabled. A machine-learning algorithm controls the feature.

We'll refer to something as a Significant Location in the following list. This is a location determined using a device's location data over time to determine where a user spends most of their day.

Clean Energy Charging activates when:

These requirements mean that it is likely for Clean Energy Charging to only activate overnight when a user is sleeping. It works alongside Optimized Battery Charging to ensure the battery health is preserved and carbon emissions are minimized.

Clean Energy Charging won't activate when traveling or in any new location outside of Significant Locations. Location data isn't shared with Apple and is only used for the algorithm.

To ensure Clean Energy Charging is active, Apple says the following features need to be activated:

As we previously mentioned, Clean Energy Charging will notify the user if charging has been suspended. It never acts in the background and does not slow a user's charging speed.

Wesley Hilliard served ten years as a Nuclear Power Electrician in the US Navy, then jumped careers in 2019. Today, he is Assistant Editor, Podcast Cohost, SEO Specialist, and Social Media Manager for AppleInsider.